top of page
Writer's pictureJim Mackley

Football Rule Changes

Updated: Dec 22, 2020

All football fans want to see more goals - and lots of them. The aim should be for at least 6 in every match. Here's how!


More and more people are watching football on television. Television viewers are much more likely to be neutral than those going to a live match. For neutral spectators football is becoming increasingly boring. We do not want to see goalless draws or teams hanging on to a 1-0 lead by packing their defence. What we want to see is goals: I suggest that the aim should be for there to be at least six of them in every match. The following proposals would:

  • Make it easier to score goals

  • Give teams an incentive to score more goals

  • Reduce the number of goals disallowed for offside.

Making it easier to score goals

The goals should be made bigger. I suggest 30cm all round (i.e. 60 cm wider and 30cm higher), or at least by the diameter of a football. This would mean that most shots which now hit the woodwork would go into the goal. A strong argument in favour of this change is that most top goalkeepers are taller now than they were when the measurements were standardised well over a hundred years ago.


Giving teams an incentive to score more goals


The points system for league games should be revised. I suggest the following cumulative system:


No goals = no points Score draw = 1 point Any win = 2points A win by a margin of 2 goals or more = 1 additional point Scoring 3 goals = 1 additional point Scoring 5 goals = 1 additional point.


Under this system, a team could obtain a maximum of five points in any one game, while the losing team could get up to two points.


Examples

0-0 draw – no points awarded 1-1 draw –both teams get 1 point

5-5 draw – both teams get 3 points

1-0 win – winners get 2 points

2-0 win – winners get 3 points

3-2 win – winners get 3 points

4-2 win – winners get 4 points

5-0 win – winners get 5 points

5-3 win – winners get 5 points, losers get 1 point


I believe that such a system would encourage teams to press for more goals, rather than defending a 1-0 lead or sitting back on a 2-0 lead. It is noteworthy that the number of tries scored in international Rugby Union matches has increased since the bonus point system has been introduced.


Reducing the number of goals disallowed for offside

I think I am in a majority in thinking that “something needs to be done about the offside rule”. Too many well-crafted “goals” are ruled out because of technical infringements of the off-side rule. As far as I can see, the main original purpose of the offside law was to stop what we as children used to call “goal hanging”. I can see that argument, but a player who has just stepped over the half-way line, can hardly be accused of goal-hanging. I believe that the aim should be to make off-sides as rare as indirect free kicks in the attacking penalty area. I offer the following suggestions for consideration:

  1. No player can be offside if he is more than 18 yards (16.5metres) from the goal line.

  2. Other than in 3 below, no player can be offside if there are two or more defenders anywhere in the penalty area.

  3. A player can, however, be given offside, if he is in an offside position (as currently defined) inside the goal area (5.5 metre/6 yard area) and there is no defender, other than the goalkeeper, in that area.

9 views

Recent Posts

See All

Comments


bottom of page